The success of a meeting depends on how how involved are the attendees and whether the chairperson has done enough to facilitate active communication.
I chair at least 3 operations meeting a week with each lasting for 1 hour. This is usually done first thing in the morning so that everyone is prep up with sufficient operational objectives for the day and week.
The challenge is always getting the team to speak up. So what I would do is go round the table to obtain updates from every member. This works well when the objective is to get everyone in the room to realize what is happening within the operations team. Issues that are raised or activities/projects that will be performed should interest other team members as everything in operations are intertwined to deliver the required services to our customers. I reckon that if any team members are only interested to do his/her stuff, s/he is not suitable to be part of an operations team where everyone and everything is dynamic and, again intertwined. Operations manager plays an important role to bond the team, assign the right people for the job and ensure that communications are not inhibited within the team. I will discuss more on Operations manager in future articles.
People do not speak up in meetings for a couple of reasons:
· They do not understand the topic
· They are not interested in the topic
· They are afraid to be penalized if the wrong thing is said
· They are too shy to speak in the room
· They have given up on a particular issue which is being brought up time and again
· The chairperson is not facilitating proper flow of discussion
· The chairperson did not communicate the purpose of meeting and its agenda
(The list can go on forever…)
Going round the table forces people to think and react but the quality of the response may not be desirable due to one or more of the reasons listed above. If you want a successful meeting with quality action items and decisions, you must first understand your attendees and their set of agenda. Do not invite someone to your meeting if they are not interested or can add value in any way. You need to get people to prepare for every single meetings by giving them very clear objectives of the meeting (for weekly meetings, you have fixed items in the agenda as well as one or 2 variables). If you know they are not prepared for the meeting, don’t waste time on him/her. Move on to the next person. If no one prepared for the meeting, adjourn the meeting and call for another one. This is to give everyone a clear message that meetings should not be treated like a time waster.
Dave’s blog (http://blogs.netapp.com/dave/2009/03/does-anyone-hav.html) has a great suggestion on how to get people to argue and challenge a proposal or decisions that are presented in meetings. However, asking, “Okay, I think we’ve fleshed out the argument in favor of the proposal well enough. Does anyone have a completely different point of view?” will not work in a room filled with shy people or people who are too afraid to speak. If they do speak, they could be the “yes-man/lady” who cannot say no to anyone. Prior to using this approach, I would suggest preparing the mindset of the attendees. They have to trust you even if they do not trust the person sitting next to him/her. Create a relaxing environment where people feels more comfortable to speak their mind without being shot down for saying their piece. If you do not feel comfortable being questioned about your decision as a manager or chairperson, then you should not expect alternative views.
So now, ask yourself, are you able to admit mistakes and accept the views of others? If yes, that’s one hurdle down. The next thing is to build a culture of active communication and involvement